Trasimene: an ancient conundrum - April 2022
When did it last rain? Well we did have some the other day and even hail and snow, but as far as I can remember it has been bone dry from New Year until the end of March. Or that’s how I remember it. Indeed, looking out across Lake Trasimeno I can see the shores of the islands high above the water line: surely another sign that we have had little or no rain.
Ian Robertson, my rainfall-recording guru, assures me that compared with the past 20 years this three month period January – March in fact got 75% of the average. But during the same period in 2019 we only got 20%. I don’t recall that! But then I seem to have a pandemic-shaped hole in my memory and events before then are often obscured. Weird.
The level of water in Lake Trasimeno has been a cause for concern since ancient times - both too high and too low. There are no rivers flowing into or out of the Lake, so it is difficult to maintain the right level. The water level varies with rainfall during the cycles of climatic conditions: this paper by researchers at Perugia University explains how the lake was too high during the ancient Roman period and again in the 15th - 19th centuries.
Roman Senator Silius Italicus wrote his epic poem ‘Punica’ in the first century AD about the Punic Wars and Book V:1-23 describes how Trasimeno came to be so named. Not only was the water of the lake very deep, such that nymph Agilla could drag Prince Trasimene into its depths, but when Hannibal arrives in 217 BC the area is described as being ‘surrounded by deep mud’ which he used to military advantage against Flaminius. In the early Mediaeval period the lake dried out considerably and villages built on the shores were later lost when waters rose again.
Overflow channel at San Savino where it goes underground
To control the water levels, the Romans created an overflow channel from San Saviano to the Tiber, and this was rebuilt in the 15 century and renewed in the 19 century. In the 20 century (see graph) falling water levels meant that drastic action had to be taken to prevent a total drying out of the Lake in the 1950s. Whilst this was effective at the time, a study by the University of Perugia published in February forecasts that if the current trend continues then Lake Trasimeno will disappear by the end of this century. Umbra Acque are currently constructing a pipeline to bring in 15 million m3 water per annum from a dam in Valfabbrica, northeast of Perugia.
Graph of Lake Trasimeno water level (cm) vs datum 257m asl since 1912
Why does this matter to us gardeners in Castiglione? Firstly, we rely on Lake Trasimeno for so much of our local environment - also recreation and visual delight. If the water level drops low for too long then the lake will become a swamp and not only will that mean (even greater) infestations of insects but overall the ecosystem will be putrid. The migrating bird populations that rely on Trasimeno as a stopping off point will be deterred. A downward spiral of death and decay.
The lake is not only affected by how much water arrives as rain but also the amount of water that is extracted for agriculture. The quality of the water that runs off the surrounding farm land is reported to be good but in reality the level of nitrates that exacerbate the growth of algae in the lake are too high. When we had a well drilled (down to 120m depth) the analysis of the aquifer water revealed unacceptably high levels of nitrates - such that it was rendered unpotable by humans.
So we gardeners need to do what we can to limit our use of water and to not put fertiliser on the garden unnecessarily.
When you are out in the garden this month - cutting back dead wood from roses and shrubs, I hope - do please resist the temptation to put fertiliser on everything. Not only will it encourage lush, quick growth that will not resist the summer drought but it will run off into the local aquifer and end up creating algae in the Lake. Compost and mulch are fine - they break down more slowly and are taken up by the plants’ own systems.
Trasimeno: always a problem - August 2024
The infernal heat of August is upon us and has been here for what seems like months already. Despite some unexpected late spring rains, Trasimeno is in a parlous state.
Trasimeno in distress: bird sanctuary La Valle in recent months (Umbria24)
The local authorities and the water company Umbra Acque are continually on the hunt for solutions to the perpetual problem - that Trasimeno is drying up and may soon disappear. Whilst the water level appeared to have returned to near ‘normal’ about ten years ago, this was a fleeting recovery. If current trends continue then the Lake will be back down to lows last seen in 2003.
Graph of Lake Trasimeno water level (cm) vs datum 257m asl since 2003
An explanation of why this is a ‘Trasimeno question’ and not an issue for the other major lakes in Italy was recently provided to the Umbria24 online newspaper. Data presented by the former mayor of Magione, Giacomo Chiodini, shows clearly that Trasimeno has a large surface area but only a small volume of water as it is so very shallow.
Great lakes of Italy compared
The great lakes in the north, Garda, Maggiore and Como, are in fact drowned alpine valleys and are extremely deep. They are also replenished by the melting ice sheets and glaciers as well as fed by rivers – whereas Trasimeno has no river water source. The northern lakes also enjoy a much bigger catchment area from which they can source their water.
Central Italian lakes Bracciano and Bolsena are also much deeper than Trasimeno, having been created from ancient extinct volcanos. Trasimeno is more of a surface feature, a ‘soup dish’ shaped depression between the surrounding hills.
All this does not provide much cheer as we continue to swelter in the hottest summer on record. Let’s hope that the Umbria Region can finally enact its plan to pipe water from the reservoir at Valfabbrica in the hills above Perugia – before it is too late.
The photo at the top of this page shows a painting of Castiglione del Lago viewed across Lake Trasimeno from Panicarola by Robert Tilleard
Many of these articles first appeared in the Castiglione del Lago monthly newsletter “Qua e là” edited by Priscilla Worsley
All text and photographs © Yvonne Barton unless stated otherwise